2007 bali climate declaration by scientists

SMH 6/12/07

An article by Matthew England puts the case for scientists being the people who should be deciding what to do about Global Warming rather than big business.

".....Yet despite these achievements, climate scientists have generally steered clear of telling the world how to set its emissions targets. The attitude has always been this: climate scientists should stick to the science, not set policy. Fair enough."

"But who is best placed to advise the world what greenhouse gas targets are needed to avoid dangerous climate change? Who should be setting the goals to reduce our carbon emissions over the coming years?"

"The answer is definitely not the fossil fuel sector. That would be like asking a tobacco company CEO whether you should quit smoking. Or a fast food chain what constitutes a healthy meal. Read "conflict of interest" in flashing neon lights."

"To be fair, we equally cannot rely on conservation societies and environmental lobby groups for advice here. They possibly have the right answers, but they are not the experts: their advice is only as good as their sources."

"Climate scientists in contrast have analysed in detail what the climatic impacts are likely to be for a whole range of greenhouse gas emissions scenarios. Much of the IPCC reports are devoted to this exercise. And this has been an ongoing activity for the past 20 years. The science is not new; we are just living at a time when people have become aware of the findings because the predictions are urgent and dire."

"A whole suite of future projections have been assembled in that time. At the high end is the "business as usual" case. One of my colleagues recently dubbed this "The George Bush" scenario. You can guess how this unfolds: we do nothing, and the planet is set on an unknown path toward unprecedented warming, severe storms, large-scale ecosystems extinctions and the displacement of tens of millions of environmental refugees."..

He then talks about the declaration, which we have produced below. It is signed by 212 of the world`s leading climate scientists.

"The Bali Climate Declaration has made the scientific view on emissions targets patently clear. It is now over to the policy makers to give the planet a decent future."

2007 Bali Climate Declaration by Scientists

This consensus document was prepared under the auspices of the Climate Change Research Centre at the University of New South Wales in Sydney, Australia.


The 2007 IPCC report, compiled by several hundred climate scientists, has unequivocally concluded that our climate is warming rapidly, and that we are now at least 90% certain that this is mostly due to human activities. The amount of carbon dioxide in our atmosphere now far exceeds the natural range of the past 650,000 years, and it is rising very quickly due to human activity. If this trend is not halted soon, many millions of people will be at risk from extreme events such as heat waves, drought, floods and storms, our coasts and cities will be threatened by rising sea levels, and many ecosystems, plants and animal species will be in serious danger of extinction.

The next round of focused negotiations for a new global climate treaty (within the 1992 UNFCCC process) needs to begin in December 2007 and be completed by 2009. The prime goal of this new regime must be to limit global warming to no more than 2 ºC above the pre-industrial temperature, a limit that has already been formally adopted by the European Union and a number of other countries.

Based on current scientific understanding, this requires that global greenhouse gas emissions need to be reduced by at least 50% below their 1990 levels by the year 2050. In the long run, greenhouse gas concentrations need to be stabilised at a level well below 450 ppm (parts per million; measured in CO2-equivalent concentration). In order to stay below 2 ºC, global emissions must peak and decline in the next 10 to 15 years, so there is no time to lose.

As scientists, we urge the negotiators to reach an agreement that takes these targets as a minimum requirement for a fair and effective global climate agreement.

Name      Title    Country
Richard Allan   Dr   United Kingdom
Richard Anthes   Dr   USA
Waleed Abdalati   Head, Cryospheric Sciences Branch   USA
Becky Alexander   Assistant Professor   USA
Ian Allison   Dr   Australia
Caspar Ammann   Research Scientist   USA
Leif Anderson   Professor   Sweden
Jean-Claude Andre   Dr   France
Natalie Andronova   Research Scientist   USA
David Archer   Professor   USA
Mike Archer   Professor. Dean of Science   Australia
Vincenzo Artale   Senior Research Scientist   Italy
Paulo Artaxo   Professor   Brazil
Karen Assmann   Dr   Norway
Dorothee Bakker   Dr   United Kingdom
Edouard Bard   Professor College de France   France
Tim Barnett   Research Marine Physicist   USA
J. Ray Bates   Professor   Ireland
Richard Bellerby   Dr   Norway
Rasmus E. Benestad   Dr   Norway
Terje Berntsen   Senior Scientist   Norway
Nathan Bindoff   Professor Physical Oceanography   Australia
Robert Bindschadler   Chief Scientist, Hydrospheric/Biospheric Laboratory   USA
Roxana Bojariu   Head, Climate Research Group   Romania
Sandrine Bony   Research Scientist   France
Laurent Bopp   Dr   France
Alberto Borges   Dr   Belgium
Philippe Bousquet   Assistant Professor   France
Pascale Braconnot   Dr   France
Raymond S. Bradley   Professor. Director. Climate System Research Center   USA
Guy Brasseur   Senior Scientist   USA
Francois-Marie Breon   Professor   France
Christopher Bretherton   Director. Program on Climate Change   USA
Victor Brovkin   Dr   Germany
Erik Buitenhuis   Dr   United Kingdom
Pep Canadell   Executive Director Global Carbon Project   Australia
Mark Cane   Professor   USA
Carlo Carraro   Professor   Italy
Anny Cazenave   Senior Scientist   France
Marie-Lise Chanin   Director of Research Emeritus   France
Sylvie Charbit   Dr   France
Robert J. Charlson   Professor   USA
John Church   Chief Research Scientist   Australia
Garry Clarke   Emeritus Professor of Geophysics   Canada
Martin Claussen   Professor. Director. Max Planck Inst.   Germany
William D. Collins   Professor and Senior Scientist   USA
Paul Crutzen   Professor   Germany/USA
Kurt M. Cuffey   Professor   USA
Valerie Daux   Dr   France
Anthony Del Genio   Physical Scientist   USA
Kenneth Denman   Senior Scientist   Canada
Robert E. Dickinson   Professor   USA
Paul Dirmeyer   Research Scientist   USA
Helge Drange   Professor   Norway
Kerry Emanuel   Professor   USA
Matthew England   Professor and ARC Federation Fellow   Australia
Ian Enting   Professor   Australia
Jean-Louis Fellous   Earth observation satellite expert   France
Jonathan Fink   Director. Global Institute of Sustainability   USA
Andreas Fischlin   Director Terrestrial Systems Ecology. ETH Zurich    Switzerland
Jacqueline Flückiger   Research Scientist   Switzerland
Chris E. Forest   Research Scientist   USA
Piers Forster   Reader in Climate Change Physics   UK
Joos Fortunat   Professor   Switzerland
Roger Francey   Senior Scientist   Australia
Helen Amanda Fricker   Associate Research Geophysicist   USA
Pierre Friedlingstein   Dr   France
Andrew D. Friend   Dr   United Kingdom
Qiang Fu   Professor   USA
Andrey Ganopolski   Scientist   Germany
Catherine Gautier   Professor   USA
Alexander Gershunov   Research Climatologist   USA
Sarah Gille   Associate Professor   USA
Nathan Gillet   Dr   UK
Valerie Gros   Dr   France
Nicolas Gruber   Professor   Switzerland
Hoshin Gupta   Professor   USA
Kimio Hanawa   Professor   Japan
Bogi Hansen   Professor   Faroe Islands
Mohamed H.A. Hassan   Professor   Italy
Klaus Hasselmann   Prof. Emeritus   Germany
Gerald Haug   Professor   Switzerland
Didier Hauglustaine   Directeur de Recherche CNRS   France
A. D. J. Haymet   Professor   USA
Gabriele Hegerl   Dr and Reader Geosciences   UK,USA
Martin Heimann   Professor. Director. Max-Planck-Inst.   Germany
Christoph Heinze   Professor in Chemical Oceanography   Norway
Ann Henderson-Sellers   Professor   Australia
Jens Hesselbjerg Christensen   Head of Climate Research Programme   Denmark
Bruce Hewitson   Professor   South Africa
Kip Hodges   Director. School of Earth & Space Exploration   United States
Georg Hoffman   Dr   France
Marika Holland   Scientist   USA
David M Holland   Professor   USA
Elisabeth A. Holland   Program Lead, Biogeosciences Program, NCAR   USA
Greg Holland   Senior Scientist Severe Weather Research and Applications   USA
Lesley Hughes   Professor   Australia
James W. Hurrell   Senior Scientist   USA
Stan Jacobs   Senior Research Scientist   USA
Eystein Jansen   Professor. Director   Norway
Truls Johannessen   Professor of Chemical Oceanography   Norway
Ian Joughin   Senior Engineer   USA
Masa Kageyama   Dr   France
Robert Kandel   Emeritus Senior Scientist   France
Georg Kaser   Professor   Austria
Ralph Keeling   Professor of Geochemistry   USA
Robert M. Key   Research Oceanographer   United States
Jeffrey Kiehl   Senior Scientist   USA
Miko Kirschbaum   Senior Scientist   New Zealand
Christine Klaas   Dr   Germany
Albert Klein Tank   Dr   Netherlands
Reto Knutti   Professor   Switzerland
Rupa Kumar Kolli   Dr   India
René Laprise   Professor. Director ESCER Centre    Canada
Corinne Le Quere   Professor   United Kingdom
Herve Le Treut   Director. Laboratoire de Meteorologie Dynamique   France
Peter Lemke   Professor   Germany
Conway Leovy   Professor Emeritus   USA
Sydney Levitus   Director. World Data Center for Oceanography   USA
Ulrike Lohmann   Professor   Switzerland
Diana Liverman   Professor   United Kingdom
Dan Lubin   Research Physicist   USA
Joachim Luther   Professor   Germany
Amanda H. Lynch   Professor and ARC Federation Fellow   Australia
Jose Antonio Marengo   Senior Scientist   Brazil
Jochem Marotzke   Professor. Director. Max Planck Inst.   Germany
Valerie Masson-Delmotte   Dr   France
Ben Matthews   Dr   Belgium
Cecilie Mauritzen   Senior Scientist   Norway
Bryant McAvaney   Senior Principal Research Scientist   Australia
James J. McCarthy   Professor of Oceanography    USA
Jeffrey J. McDonnell   Professor and Richardson Chair in Watershed Science   USA
Trevor J. McDougall   Dr   Australia
Tony McMichael   Professor   Australia
Ben McNeil   Queen Elizabeth II Research Fellow   Australia
Nicolas Metzl   Dr   France
Elisabeth Michel   Dr   France
Guy Midgley   Dr   South Africa
Arthur J. Miller   Research Oceanographer   USA
Gunnar Myhre   Senior Scientist   Norway
Neville Nicholls   Professor   Australia
Richard D. Norris   Professor and Curator, SIO Geological Collections   USA
Daniel Olago   Dr. Senior Lecturer University of Nairobi   Kenya
Michael Oppenheimer   Professor   USA
Bette Otto-Bliesner   Senior Scientist   USA
Jonathon Overpeck   Director Institute for the Study of Planet Earth   USA
Didier Paillard   Dr   France
Wm. Richard Peltier   University Professor of Physics   Canada
Andy Pitman   Professor   Australia
Serge Planton   Senior Scientist   France
Gian-Kasper Plattner   Dr   Switzerland
Jan Polcher   Directeur de Recherche du CNRS   France
Michael J. Prather   Fred Kavli Professor   USA
Stefan Rahmstorf   Professor of Physics of the Oceans   Germany
Philip Rasch   Senior Scientist   USA
Michael Raupach   Dr   Australia
Chris Reason   Professor. Oceanography   South Africa
James Renwick   Science Leader, Climate Variability & Change    New Zealand
Ulf Riebesell   Professor   Germany
Stephen R. Rintoul   Dr   Australia
Johan Rockström   Associate Professor   Sweden
Terry L. Root   University Faculty, Senior Fellow   USA
Lynn M. Russell   Professor of Atmospheric Chemistry   USA
Toshiro Saino   Professor   Japan
Christoph Schär   Professor in Atmospheric Sciences, ETH Zurich   Switzerland
John Schellnhuber   Professor   Germany
Gavin Schmidt   Research Scientist, NASA GISS   USA
Stephen H. Schneider   Professor   USA
Birgit Schneider   Dr   France
Michael Schulz   Senior Scientist   France
Richard Seager   Senior Research Scientist    USA
Jeffrey P. Severinghaus   Professor of Geosciences   USA
Drew Shindell   Senior Scientist and Lecturer   USA
W James Shuttleworth   Professor. Director NSF SAHRA Center   USA
Murugesu Sivapalan   Professor   USA
John P. Smol   Professor   Canada
Olga Solomina   Dr   Russia
Richard Somerville   Professor   USA
Will Steffen   Professor   Australia
Thomas Stocker   Professor   Switzerland
Kristof Sturm   Associate Professor   Sweden
John Sulston   Dr   United Kingdom
Didier Swingedouw   Dr   France
Lynne D. Talley   Professor   USA
Karl E. Taylor   Dr   USA
Fichefet Thierry   Professor   Belgium
Helmuth Thomas   Associate Professor. Canada Reseach Chair   Canada
Jerry Tjiputra   Dr   Indonesia
Kevin Trenberth   Dr. Head, Climate Analysis Section   USA
Peter A. Troch   Professor   USA
Carol Turley   Dr   United Kingdom
A.S Unnikrishnan   Senior Scientist   India
Francisco P. J. Valero   Director Atmospheric Research Laboratory   USA
Rob Van Dorland   Dr   The Netherlands
Ricardo Villalba   Director IANIGLA   Argentina
Martin Visbeck   Professor   Germany
Andrea Volbers   Dr   Norway
Thorsten Wagener   Assistant Professor   USA
John Wahr   Professor   USA
Warren M. Washington   Senior Scientist   USA
Bob Wasson   Professor   Australia
Andrew Watson   Professor   United Kingdom
Ian G. Watterson   Dr   Australia
Andrew Weaver   Professor   Canada
Peter J. Webster   Professor   USA
Ray F. Weiss   Professor   USA
James W.C. White   Professor   USA
Jürgen Willebrand   Professor Emeritus   Germany
Larry Winter   Deputy Director NCAR   USA
Carl Wunsch   Professor of Physical Oceanography   USA
Xubin Zeng   Professor   USA
Guang J. Zhang   Research Meteorologist   USA